The Cheap Structure That May End Up Costing A Lot

Every week, a digital nomad or content creator contacts us after being advised to set up a US LLC, usually in Wyoming or Delaware. The adviser is typically an offshore formation agent, a YouTube channel, or a provider based in South Asia or Eastern Europe. The pitch is always the same: $1,200 per year, tax-free income, total privacy, no reporting obligations.

It is not simple. It is a structure that solves nothing, creates new problems, and is being sold by people who either do not understand international tax or do not care.

This article explains what actually happens when a non-US citizen with no US residence sets up a US LLC to run an international business, and why there are better options.

‍

The Pitch

The typical US LLC pitch to digital nomads and content creators goes like this:

1. "LLCs are tax-transparent." The LLC itself does not pay US federal income tax. Income passes through to the member. If the member is not a US resident, there is no US tax.
2. "Wyoming (or Delaware) has no state income tax on LLCs." True, and presented as though it solves something.
3. "It's private. Wyoming doesn't require public disclosure of members." The implication is that nobody can find out who owns the LLC.
4. "You can open a US bank account." This is sold as a feature, as though banking access requires a US entity.
5. "Total cost: $1,200 per year." Formation, registered agent, annual report. Done.

Each of these claims is either incomplete, misleading, or wrong. Here is what actually happens.

‍

Problem 1: Pass-Through Taxation Means the Tax Follows the Member

A single-member LLC is a "disregarded entity" under US tax law (Treasury Regulation section 301.7701-3). The LLC's income is treated as the member's personal income.

This is presented as a benefit, but think about what it actually means. If the income is treated as your personal income, it is taxed wherever you are personally tax resident. The LLC does not eliminate the tax. It moves the question from "where is the entity taxed?" to "where is the member taxed?"

For a digital nomad, that question has three possible answers:

1. You are tax resident somewhere. Most digital nomads are tax resident in a country. If you hold a UK passport and spend time in the UK, HMRC may assert tax residency under the Statutory Residence Test. If you are South African, SARS may assert residency under the ordinarily resident test or the physical presence test. If you spend significant time in any country with a residency-based tax system, that country's revenue authority has a potential claim on your worldwide income, including the LLC's income that passes through to you.
2. You are tax resident nowhere. This is the "perpetual traveler" theory. The problem is that almost all tax authorities do not accept this. Tax authorities actively contest the claim that a person is resident nowhere and no treaty relief is available to defend these claims. Being resident nowhere is legally possible but practically dangerous, because the burden of proof is on you when any country's revenue authority comes calling.
3. You are tax resident in a no-tax jurisdiction. If you have genuinely established residency in a jurisdiction with no personal income tax (Dubai, the Cayman Islands, or certain Caribbean jurisdictions), the LLC's pass-through income is not taxed because you are not taxed. But this has nothing to do with the LLC. You could earn the income personally, through a sole proprietorship, or through any other vehicle, and the result would be the same. The LLC adds cost and complexity without adding value.

In none of these scenarios does the US LLC provide a tax benefit. It either makes no difference or makes things worse.

‍

Problem 2: US-Sourced Income Creates US Tax Obligations

This is where the pitch falls apart most catastrophically for content creators.

If your LLC earns income that is sourced in the United States, the US asserts a right to tax that income regardless of where you live. For a content creator, this is a real risk as the payer is often a US company like Youtube, TikTok, OnlyFans, and many more.

Consider the revenue streams of a typical digital nomad or content creator:

1. Advertising revenue. If your audience is global, a substantial proportion of your ad revenue is generated by US viewers. YouTube, Google AdSense, and most major ad networks treat advertising revenue paid by US companies as US-sourced income.
2. Affiliate commissions. If you promote products or services sold by US companies to US consumers, the commissions may be characterised as US-sourced.
3. Sponsorship deals. If the sponsor is a US company and the content is directed at a US audience, the payment may be US-sourced.
4. Digital product sales. If US customers purchase your courses, e-books, or templates, that revenue has a US nexus.

The US tax treatment depends on whether the income is classified as Effectively Connected Income (ECI) or Fixed, Determinable, Annual, Periodical (FDAP) income:

1. ECI is income connected with a US trade or business. A non-resident alien engaged in a US trade or business through an LLC is taxed on ECI at graduated rates (up to 37%). The LLC must file a US tax return (Form 1040-NR), and the member must obtain an ITIN.
2. FDAP income (royalties, rents, dividends, certain service fees) is subject to a flat 30% withholding tax at source, unless reduced by a tax treaty. The UK has a tax treaty with the US that may reduce withholding on certain income. South Africa also has a treaty. But treaty benefits require proper documentation (Form W-8BEN), and the analysis of which income category applies to ad revenue, affiliate commissions, and sponsorships is not straightforward.

The formation agent who sold the LLC for $1,200 did not explain any of this. They will not be the one paying the back taxes or filing the delinquent returns or unintentionally committing US federal tax evasion.

‍

Problem 3: The Privacy Argument Is Weak

Wyoming does not require public disclosure of LLC members or managers on formation documents. This provides privacy from casual public searches, and it is the primary "privacy" benefit that formation agents sell.

What they do not mention is the federal overlay. The Corporate Transparency Act (CTA), enacted in 2021, originally required virtually all US LLCs to report their beneficial ownership information to the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN). In March 2025, FinCEN issued an interim final rule that exempted domestic entities (including all US-formed LLCs) from these reporting requirements, narrowing the obligation to foreign-formed entities registered to do business in the US.

However, this exemption exists by regulation, not by statute. The underlying CTA statute still authorises FinCEN to require reporting from domestic entities, and the scope could be broadened again by future rulemaking. The regulatory environment is unstable, and relying on a temporary administrative exemption is not a foundation for long-term structuring.

More fundamentally, Wyoming's state-level privacy does not protect you from:

1. The IRS. A foreign-owned single-member LLC must file Form 5472 and a pro-forma Form 1120 annually, disclosing the owner's identity and all reportable transactions. Failure to file carries penalties of USD 25,000 per return.
2. US financial institutions. KYC and AML requirements mean your bank knows exactly who you are, and reports to the IRS under Chapter 3 withholding and FATCA obligations.
3. Your home country's tax authority. CRS (Common Reporting Standard) and bilateral information exchange agreements give foreign revenue authorities access to information about your US financial accounts and entity interests.
4. US courts. Discovery and subpoena powers reach through the LLC to its beneficial owner.

The privacy is a veneer. It stops a casual Google or company search. It does not stop the US government or any party with legal authority to look. A properly structured international arrangement, using jurisdictions and vehicles designed for genuine structural privacy, achieves much better tax planning and asset protection benefits.

‍

Problem 4: You Do Not Need a US Entity for US Banking

One of the selling points of a US LLC is the ability to open a US bank account. Formation agents present this as though a US entity is the only way to access USD banking and payment infrastructure.

This has not been true for years. The rise of international neobanks and fintech platforms has made it straightforward to obtain USD-denominated accounts, payment processing, and merchant services without a US entity. Providers such as Mercury, Wise Business, Relay, Ramp, and others routinely onboard foreign-incorporated companies, including IBCs and entities from zero-tax jurisdictions, provided the applicant can satisfy standard KYC requirements.

A properly structured international entity can open accounts in multiple currencies across multiple jurisdictions without creating an unnecessary nexus with the US tax system. We regularly assist our clients with banking introductions for foreign entities, including institutions that offer USD accounts, SWIFT access, and integration with major payment platforms.

The US LLC adds a US tax filing obligation, potential withholding exposure, and IRS reporting on the account. A non-US entity with a USD account at an international bank or neobank avoids all of this. The banking access argument for a US LLC is a solution to a problem that no longer exists.

‍

Problem 5: The Real Cost Is Not $1,200

The formation agent's fee is $1,200 per year. The actual cost of running a US LLC properly as a non-US person includes:

1. US tax return preparation. If the LLC has ECI or FDAP income, a Form 1040-NR must be filed. Cost: USD 1,000-3,000 per year for a competent international tax preparer.
2. ITIN application. The member needs an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number. Cost: USD 200-500.
3. Form 5472 and pro-forma Form 1120. Required annually for foreign-owned single-member LLCs. Penalty for non-filing: USD 25,000 per return. Cost of preparation: USD 500-1,500.
4. State annual report and registered agent. The $1,200 covers this.
5. FATCA/CRS compliance. Your home country (or countries) may require you to disclose the LLC and its income. Failing to disclose creates penalties that dwarf the cost of the structure.
6. Professional advice. You need someone who understands both US and international tax to tell you whether ECI or FDAP applies to your specific income streams, whether treaty benefits are available, and what your filing obligations are. Cost: USD 2,000-5,000 for an initial opinion.

The $1,200 structure actually costs USD 5,000-10,000 per year to run properly. Most people do not run it properly. They do not file US returns, do not report the LLC to their home country, and do not claim treaty benefits. They are accumulating compliance failures that will compound until a revenue authority notices.

‍

What Actually Works

For a digital nomad or content creator who has genuinely left their home country and is building an international business, the structure needs to achieve three things:

1. Entity-level tax neutrality. The entity that receives the income should be in a jurisdiction that does not tax foreign-sourced income.
2. Commercial privacy. The beneficial owner's commercial affairs should not be visible to competitors, counterparties, or the general public through entity registers.
3. Avoidance of unnecessary nexus with jurisdictions where the client has no genuine business or personal connection.

A US LLC achieves none of these. A properly structured international arrangement - typically a Private Interest Foundation holding an International Business Company (IBC) - achieves all three. The combined structure costs approximately USD 12,000-20,000 per year, which is comparable to the true cost of running a US LLC properly, but it actually delivers the benefits the LLC promises and fails to provide. For smaller budgets, a standalone IBC with nominee directors achieves entity-level tax neutrality and meaningful privacy at approximately USD 6,500-10,000 per year, with the foundation added later as the business grows.

We explain the Foundation + IBC structure in detail, including how it works, what it costs, and how to get started, in our companion article: The Foundation + IBC Structure.

‍

The Perpetual Traveller Problem

Many digital nomads operate on the assumption that they are tax resident nowhere. The US LLC pitch feeds into this assumption: if you are not resident anywhere, and the LLC is tax-transparent, then no country taxes the income.

This is a dangerous assumption. Revenue authorities around the world are increasingly sophisticated at establishing tax residency for mobile individuals. Common triggers include:

1. Spending more than 183 days in a country (the standard threshold in many jurisdictions, though the tests vary).
2. Maintaining a permanent home or habitual abode in a country, even if you do not spend the majority of the year there.
3. Having a centre of vital interests (family, economic ties, social connections) in a country.
4. Citizenship-based taxation. The United States taxes its citizens on worldwide income regardless of where they live. Eritrea does the same. If you are a US citizen, none of the above analysis helps you.
5. Departure provisions. Some countries (including Australia, under the resides test in subsection 6(1) of the ITAA 1936 and Taxation Ruling TR 2023/1) will assert continued residency unless the departure is permanent and accompanied by a clear break in ties.

The safe approach is to establish genuine tax residency in a jurisdiction with a favourable personal tax regime (or no personal income tax) before building the structure. The structure then operates in the context of a known, defensible tax position. The unsafe approach is to assume you are resident nowhere and hope nobody asks.

‍

Who Sells You the Structure Matters

The US LLC is not just a bad structure for non-US digital nomads. It is a symptom of how it is sold.

The typical LLC formation agent operates a transactional business. They incorporate the entity, provide a registered agent address, and send you a login to download your documents. The relationship ends at checkout. If you have a question three months later about how to open a bank account, how to handle withholding on a sponsorship payment, or what to do when a platform asks for a Tax Identification Number, you are either on your own or paying per enquiry. Most of these providers charge USD 50-150 per support request, assuming they respond at all.

This model works for simple domestic formations where the client already has an accountant and a lawyer. It does not work for a non-resident digital nomad who needs ongoing guidance on banking, compliance, tax residency, and platform onboarding across multiple jurisdictions. The problems we see most often from clients who come to us after using a generic formation agent include:

1. No guidance on US filing obligations. The client was never told about Form 5472, Form 1040-NR, or the ITIN requirement. They discover the obligations years later, often when a bank or platform flags a compliance issue.
2. No assistance with banking. Opening a bank account for an offshore entity is not trivial. It requires KYC documentation, corporate resolutions, and often a letter of introduction or reference from a professional adviser. Formation agents do not provide this.
3. No understanding of the client's tax position. The formation agent does not ask where the client is tax resident, what type of income the entity will receive, or whether there are treaty implications. The structure is sold without any analysis of whether it is appropriate.
4. No adaptation as circumstances change. When the client moves countries, changes platforms, takes on employees, or needs to restructure, the formation agent has no capacity to advise. The client must find a new adviser, often at significant cost, to fix a structure that should never have been implemented in the first place.

Cadena International operates on a fundamentally different model. We do not sell formations. We build and maintain structures. The relationship does not end at incorporation. We work with our clients on an ongoing basis to ensure that the structure continues to meet their needs as their business evolves. This includes:

1. Banking introductions. We assist with account opening at international banks and neobanks, including preparation of KYC documentation, corporate resolutions, and letters of introduction.
2. Platform onboarding. We prepare the compliance documentation that payment processors, content platforms, and merchant acquirers require for offshore entities.
3. Compliance management. We monitor filing obligations across jurisdictions and coordinate with local advisers to ensure nothing is missed.
4. A network of professional advisors. Our clients have access to a curated network of international tax accountants, auditors, and specialist advisers across multiple jurisdictions. When a client needs a tax opinion on treaty withholding, a transfer pricing analysis, or personal tax advice in a new country of residence, we coordinate with the right professional rather than leaving the client to find one on their own.
5. Restructuring. When circumstances change, we restructure. The foundation can be added later. The IBC can be migrated. The banking relationships can be moved. We handle this as part of the ongoing relationship, not as a separate engagement at a separate cost.

The cost is higher than a formation agent's checkout price, because the service is substantively different. You are not buying a document. You are engaging a team that understands your business and your obligations, and that remains available when you need them.

‍

Conclusion

A US LLC costs $1,200 per year from the formation agent. For a non-US digital nomad or content creator, it delivers: pass-through taxation that follows you wherever you are tax resident, potential US tax on US-sourced income (which is most of your income if your audience is American), mandatory IRS disclosure of your identity through Form 5472, reporting on your US bank account to the IRS and onward to your home country's revenue authority, and a set of filing obligations that the formation agent never mentioned.

A properly structured international arrangement, using vehicles designed for this purpose, delivers genuine tax neutrality at the entity level, genuine privacy, and no unnecessary nexus with the US tax system. It costs more than $1,200 from a formation agent, because the people who build these structures are qualified to do so and the jurisdictions involved are designed for this purpose.

The cheap option is not cheap. It is a compliance liability dressed up as a tax solution. If you are building a location-independent business and earning meaningful income, the structure needs to be built properly from the start. Fixing it later always costs more.

Read our companion article to see what a properly built structure looks like.

‍

This material is produced by Cadena International. It is intended to provide general information and opinions on legal topics, current at the time of first publication. The contents do not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such.

‍